Locked-In Syndrome – why this must end tomorrow July 19th !

I came across this blog recently and thought exerpts were appropriate for tomorrow. Sunetra Gupta has been quiet for the last few months since her original predictions of herd immunity have failed to happen, but I still respect her views. “Zero COVID is unachievable, write Paul Dolan (LSE) and Sunetra Gupta (University of Oxford). Continuing to impose restrictions inflicts disproportionate harm on the young, small businesses and creative industries.

We were extremely disappointed to hear that the remaining lockdown restrictions would not be lifted in the UK on 21 June. In extending restrictions because of the Delta variant, the government decided that those who stood most to gain from the delay – vulnerable individuals who have not yet been vaccinated – are more important than those who will lose out enormously: the younger generation, the creative industries, and the many smaller enterprises that will not survive after these periods of restrictions. They decided that the benefits in making people feel safer from delaying were greater than the significant hedonic and economic costs from ruining many people’s and business’s plans. We think they got these calculations wrong.

Photo: Leo Reynolds via a CC-BY-NC-SA 2.0 licence

However, we are where we are, and so what matters now is that all restrictions are lifted, once and for all tomorrow 19 July. There are two, perhaps even more fundamental, reasons why 19 July must genuinely be “Freedom Day”. The first relates to the social contract between different groups in society, and between citizens and the state. It should be worrying to anyone concerned with the health and wellbeing of all groups in society that those who will almost certainly call for further extension to some of the restrictions continue to refer only to the (possible and questionable) benefits of doing so. Vaccines have now largely broken the link between infection and serious illness. They can never sever it entirely. All those people who have rolled up their sleeves to be jabbed in an effort to restore basic liberties must now be wondering what more needs to be done for a return to “normal”.

The second reason why tomorrow must be the date on which all restrictions end is because any other decision will imply that we are effectively pursuing a zero COVID policy. The journey towards an endemic equilibrium will inevitably involve an increase in rates of infection. Pockets of susceptibility will remain (as they have in Bolton, for example) or re-emerge as the infection-blocking effects of natural immunity and vaccines wear off. Within each of these pockets, infections will rise and decline (as they have in Bolton) as people acquire (or re-acquire) immunity. Models which ignore the impact of naturally acquired immunity, and ascribe all the decline in infections to interventions, tend to produce quite outlandish forecasts for what may happen when restrictions are removed, and they also tend to assign improbable increases in transmissibility to new variants which may come to dominate in these spikes.

A key point that has been missed in these discussions is that the reproduction rate (R) for an endemic disease is equal to 1 and not 0. We should expect that the prevalence of infectious individuals will hover around one in a hundred when we reach this point. Whatever their impact on spread, imposing harmful restrictions whenever infection rates exhibit an increase is a policy in pursuit of R=0 rather than R=1. Tomorrow must be the day on which the government finally delivers on what it claims to be their goal; namely, the kind of endemic equilibrium which we have learnt to live with for a host of other respiratory pathogens – and not zero COVID. It is also the day on which we should stop presenting data on the number of daily infections. This number has no real meaning once the link between infection and disease has been broken, and we are now reaching an endemic equilibrium. It will only serve to further scare a population who have been made to feel afraid, and disproportionately so, for far too long.

Many countries around the world are finally accepting that we cannot remove COVID from society, even those, such as Singapore, which have actively sought to keep the virus out. Policy makers must now remove lockdowns from their COVID response.

Youtube video from above Singapore article

Click full source This post represents the views of the authors and not those of the COVID-19 blog, nor LSE.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: